After passage of the OBBBA on July 4, 2025, the White House issued an executive order three days later that directs the IRS Commissioner to revisit and revise IRS guidance on current renewable energy start of construction policy, requiring new and revised guidance within 45 days of OBBBA enactment (i.e., by August 18, 2025). The directive appears to direct the IRS commissioner to eliminate the start of construction safe harbor guidance described above. If this is indeed the case, we believe the directives in this executive order will not be legally enforceable. Media news reports suggest the executive order fulfilled a promise to Republican holdouts in the House of Representatives, who had threatened to vote against the Senate-passed version of the OBBBA.
The IRS is authorized to interpret IRC provisions, but it must comply with the Administrative Procedure Act (APA). If the IRS substantially changes prior guidance, it is required by the APA to undertake notice and comment rulemaking. Courts would likely rule that a sudden elimination of the start of construction safe harbor policy without following APA procedure is arbitrary and capricious.
Overwhelming legal precedent invalidates new IRS regulations or guidance that unfairly penalizes taxpayers who reasonably relied on prior rules. Under the doctrines of equitable estoppel and reasonable reliance, a taxpayer who begins construction under valid safe harbor guidance can argue that they should not be penalized for a subsequent guidance change — especially where no abuse or manipulation occurred. That said, it is highly unlikely that most taxpayers will need to take legal action. This is because a probability approaching certainty exists that if new guidance comprising a radical departure from previous guidance is issued, a legal challenge will be filed by the owners of an adversely impacted utility-scale solar project… or their tax credit eligibility insurers.
The IRS has historically issued safe harbor guidance on when construction begins for energy projects eligible for the Investment Tax Credit (ITC) under IRC §48. Most recently, IRS Notices 2018-59, 2020-41 and 2021-41 allowed taxpayers who begin construction by incurring at least 5% of project costs, or by starting physical construction work, to preserve ITC eligibility, provided the project is completed within four years after construction start. This framework has been widely relied upon by solar developers, investors, lenders, and tax credit eligibility insurers.
A new IRS rule or notice that limits ITC safe harbor eligibility to projects placed in service by December 31, 2027 — regardless of construction start date — would be subject to legal challenge and would not likely be held legally valid and enforceable, especially if the new guidance tries to retroactively deny the legacy safe harbor rules to projects that have already met one of the two safe harbor requirements before any new guidance is issued.